SaaS Agreements – International Agreements – Interest on Late Payments

SaaS customers often delay payment of invoices. In order to protect your SaaS business and improve cash flow, SaaS suppliers usually include the right to claim interest on late payments in the terms of their SaaS agreement or rely on the statutory right to interest under the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 (“Act”). However, following the decision in Martrade Shipping and Transport GmbH v United Enterprises Corporation SaaS suppliers should be aware of the limitations of relying upon the Act, particularly where the SaaS customer or SaaS supplier is a non UK entity.

Contractual Right to Claim Interest

SaaS suppliers can state a specific interest rate in their SaaS agreement terms under which interest for any late payment will be claimed. This can be a number i.e. 5%, or a reference to an index i.e. the European Central Bank base rate, or a combination of both i.e. the Bank of England base rate + 2%. The interest rate specified can be higher or lower than the statutory rate.

Statutory Right to Claim Interest

Alternatively, SaaS suppliers can simply say nothing about interest in the SaaS agreement and rely upon their statutory right to claim interest on late payments from a business customer (BTB) under the Act. The statutory interest rate to be applied is the applicable Bank of England Base Rate plus 8%.

Right to Claim Compensation

In addition to claiming statutory interest from a SaaS customer, under the Act SaaS suppliers can claim a fixed amount of compensation. The amount is based upon the amount of the outstanding invoice:

  • £40 – for debts less than £1,000;
  • £70 – for debts between £1,000 to £9,999; and
  • £100 – for debts over £10,000.

Recovery of Costs

Since the 16th of March 2013 SaaS suppliers have the additional right to claim the difference between the fixed compensation amount and their reasonable costs in recovering the debt e.g. the costs of appointing a debt recovery company or lawyer. However this right only applies to debts accrued after the 16th of March 2013.

Limitation to the Right to Claim Statutory Interest

Following the decision in Martrade in June 2014 the High Court disallowed a claim for interest for late payment under the Act on the basis that the parties had no substantial connection to England. Both parties were non-English entities but the contract was governed by English law and provided for arbitration in London.

The restriction imposed by the court is nothing new, it is included in section 12 of the Act, but many SaaS suppliers are unaware of it. Section 12 of the Act only permits the application of statutory interest to late payments if one or both of two further requirements are fulfilled:

  • There must be a significant connection between the contract and England; or
  • the contract must be one which would be governed by English law apart from the choice of law.

The High Court said that the Act did not apply in this case as by simply including a London arbitration or English court jurisdiction clause in the contract was not a connecting factor, as the decision to have disputes heard in London does not connect the substantive transaction itself to England. This therefore prevented the application of the Act and excluded the parties the right to claim penalty interest under the Act.

Implications for International SaaS Agreements

The above decision does not however mean that the application of the Act will be excluded from all international SaaS agreements. The Act and the high interest rate payable under it will apply if there is a substantial connection between the SaaS agreement and England

A substantial connection could for example be:

  • the SaaS supplier or the SaaS customer being an English entity;
  • England being the place of performance of obligations under the SaaS agreement;
  • where the parties carry out some relevant part of the SaaS services in England; or
  • where the SaaS agreement is governed by English law apart from the choice of English law.

Help

Irene Bodle is an IT lawyer specialising in SaaS agreements with over 15 years experience in the IT sector. If you require assistance with any SaaS, ASP, software on demand contracts or any other IT legal issues contact me:

irene.bodle@bodlelaw.com
www.bodlelaw.com

Speaker at the Berlin CloudConf 2013.

To register for my newsletter click here

______________________________________________________

Other related articles:

Interest from Customers who Pay Late – BTB

In the current economic climate, business customers often deliberately delay payment of invoices. Protect your business and improve your cash flow, by exerting your right to claim interest on late payments.

Is an interest clause required in the contract?

No. There is no requirement to have an interest clause in your contract. You have a statutory right to claim interest on late payments from a business customer (BTB). The statutory interest rate applicable is the Bank of England Base Rate + 8%. At the time of writing the currently applicable rate is 8.5%.

What interest rate can be specified in the contract?

You can choose which rate shall apply. This can be a number i.e. 7%, or a reference to an index i.e. the European Central Bank base rate, or a combination of both i.e. the Bank of England base rate + 2%. The interest rate specified can be higher or lower than the statutory rate.

Does the contractual or the statutory interest rate apply?

If you specify an interest rate in your contract, the  statutory rate will  not apply, even if the rate specified is lower.

Disadvantages of having a contractual interest clause

1. By specifying an interest rate in your contract you are inviting a business customer to negotiate a lower rate.

2. If you have a weaker bargaining position, you may have to agree to a rate much lower than 8.5%.

3. Time and money could be wasted on lengthy discussions about which index to use and the % rate applicable.

4. Many business customers are not aware of your rights. Saying nothing about interest in the contract can result in avoiding protracted negotiations on this issue, and the statutory rate will apply automatically.

Can a business customer exclude your right to charge interest in the contract?

No. Such a clause will be invalid and unenforceable.

Do you have to enforce your right to claim interest?

No. It is up to you to decide, if, and when, it is appropriate to enforce your right to claim interest from business customers.

Calculating interest

Your terms and conditions should state when payment is due i.e. within 14 days of the date of invoices. Interest will be calculated and payable from day 15.

As a matter of good practice send your customer a payment reminder before exercising your right to claim interest. They may simply have overlooked your invoice!

IMPORTANT NOTE: please note that the above only applies to BTB contracts.

Help

If you need assistance with interest clauses or your terms and conditions generally contact:

irene.bodle@bodlelaw.com
www.bodlelaw.com

To register for my newsletter click here

______________________________________________________

Other related articles: